Welcome to Setliff Insurance Agency

Our agency and Erie Insurance are committed to maintaining a high standard of excellence and establishing a strong relationship of mutual trust and service to each of our clients.

We offer personal attention, full-time professional service, competitive pricing, a broad range of insurance products to meet your needs and an experienced staff of conscientious professionals.

Our Philosophy of Service Continues Today

"To provide our Policyholders with as near perfect protection, as near perfect service, as is humanly possible, and to do so at the lowest possible cost."

That was Erie Insurance's guiding philosophy back in 1925 when the company was founded and one that continues to lead the way for Example Insurance Group. Our agency is committed to this promise from Erie Insurance. Thank you for visiting our Web site. We value your opinion. Contact us with any questions or concerns.


Your first option is always to contact our office immediately. We can generally report your claim directly from our office and give you help and advice during the claims process.

However, should you need to speak with someone after hours, the following numbers will call directly to the companies' claims offices.

Erie ( 800 ) 367-3743

EIGlass ( for Erie's glass claims only ) ( 800 ) 552-3743

Progressive ( 800 ) 274-4499

GMAC ( 800 ) 468-3466

Mercury ( 800 ) 489-7001

Foremost ( 800 ) 527-3907

Again, always feel free to call our office directly to help in the claims process.